Fr James W Garrard began his rectorship at St Stephen's on July 2, 1968, immediately plunging into the work of the parish and becoming widely involved in community activites. He placed emphasis on parish activites--youth programs, men's groups, etc--being devotional first and fellowship evolving from that rather than simply being social get-togethers. As time went by, the parish grew in numbers and in faithful Sunday attendance, even overcoming the closing of Perrin Air Force Base in 1971, when St Stephen's lost 82 active members, military people who were transferred elsewhere. Two years later, All Saints' Chapel was built, as well as the much-needed two-story education building, and the Garth was developed. Then, in the 1990s, as the parish continued to grow, further renovations were made and property across the street purchased.
Fr Garrard placed great emphasis on the parish fulfilling its calling to worship God and to serve His people where they were, and increasingly people became involved in St Stephen's to do exactly that. In his last "official" words as rector of St Stephen's, Fr Garrard wrote, "Each person who has worshipped here has altered this parish; each prayer that has risen within these walls has hallowed its atmosphere."
Having suffered a stroke, Fr Garrard retired as rector of St Stephen's and became rector emeritus in 1995.